International Conference on the Advancement of Silicon Photomultipliers

Europe/Berlin
Palais Hirsch, Schwetzingen

Palais Hirsch, Schwetzingen

Schlossplatz, 2 68723 Schwetzingen ‎
A.Nepomuk Otte (GATECH, School of Physics & Center for Relativistic Astrophysics) , Herbert Orth (GSI, Darmstadt)
Description

This international conference will be a meeting of scientists and technical experts working with SiPMs. 

ICASiPM brings together experts from around the world to discuss the latest developments in silicon photomultipliers, future directions, and most importantly, the standardization of SiPM characterization.

The effort to standardize SiPM characterization has become imminent due to the rapid improvement of SiPMs in recent years and its equally rapid growing user community. Only by standardizing measurement procedures will it be possible to compare devices from different producers and results obtained by different users in a meaningful way, thus considerably accelerating development cycles of SiPM applications.

We invite everyone who is interested in the standardization effort to participate in one or more working group before the meeting takes place. Each working group is tasked to prepare recommendations on their respective topic, which will then be discussed at the meeting. All working groups can be joined by contacting the respective convener listed here.

All recommendations will be published and be publicly available.

Although the standardization of SiPM characterization is a main driver of this meeting we welcome contributions that discuss anything SiPM related.

​Conference Website: http://icasipm.org

Supported by:

Poster
Participants
  • Adam Para
  • Adriano Di Giovanni
  • Albert Lehmann
  • Alberto Gola
  • Alexander Hahn
  • Andrea Wilms
  • Andrii Nagai
  • Anja Meergans
  • Antonio Ciarlone
  • Ardavan Ghassemi
  • Arseniy Rybnikov
  • Azer Sadigov
  • Brahim Mehadji
  • Chiara Nociforo
  • Christian Dille
  • Christopher Hils
  • Claudio Piemonte
  • Cyril Alispach
  • Daniel Durini
  • David Gascon
  • Deborah Herbert
  • Dejun Han
  • Delia Tosi
  • Derek Strom
  • Dieter Renker
  • Dominik Neise
  • Elena Popova
  • Erika Garutti
  • Esteban Venialgo
  • Etiennette Auffray
  • Eugen Engelmann
  • Fabio Acerbi
  • Fabrice Retiere
  • Farid Ahmadov
  • Florian Reisenhofer
  • Frédéric Vachon
  • Giacomo Gallina
  • Hans-Christian Schultz-Coulon
  • Herbert Orth
  • Hiroyasu Tajima
  • Isabelle Ansseau
  • Ivano Sarra
  • Jarek Baszak
  • Jean-Francois Pratte
  • Jian Liu
  • Johannes Breuer
  • Johannes Schumacher
  • Kai SU
  • Karl Ziemons
  • Karol Lang
  • Katharina Henjes-Kunst
  • Ken Suzuki
  • Khayala Aliguliyeva
  • Kushpil Vasilij
  • Luca Doria
  • Lukas Gruber
  • Maik Biroth
  • Marco Lopez
  • Mathieu Dupont
  • Michael Wagenpfeil
  • Nepomuk Otte
  • Nicolaus Kratochwil
  • Nikolay Anfimov
  • Paolo Traina
  • Patrick Achenbach
  • Pin Lv
  • Quirin Weitzel
  • Rainer Richter
  • Rainer Stamen
  • Razmik Mirzoyan
  • Robert Klanner
  • Sara Cerioli
  • Sascha Krause
  • Sean Stoll
  • Sergei Dolinsky
  • Sergey Klemin
  • Sergey Kononov
  • Sergey Vinogradov
  • Shahar Levy
  • Shashank Kumar
  • Slawomir Mianowski
  • Stefan Brunner
  • Stefan Gundacker
  • Stefano Merzi
  • Thomas Ganka
  • Thomas Tsang
  • Tiancheng Zhong
  • Vera Stankova
  • Veronica Regazzoni
  • Vishnu Zutshi
  • Wataru Ootani
  • Wei Shen
  • Wenqi Yan
  • William Nalti
  • Yi Qiang
  • Yonathan Munwes
  • Yue Tao
  • Yuri Musienko
  • Yusuke Uchiyama
  • Zhenxiong Yuan
  • Ziraddin Sadygov
    • 09:00 10:30
      Registration and Coffee
    • 10:30 11:40
      Opening Session
      Convener: Prof. Herbert Orth (GSI)
      • 10:30
        Conference Introduction 10m
        Speaker: Prof. A. Nepomuk Otte (Georgia Tech)
      • 10:40
        Problems in the Appearance of SiPMs: A Brief History and Perspectives 30m
        A brief history on the development of the micropixel avalanche photodiodes – MAPDs (or silicon photomultipliers SiPMs) is presented since the 80s years of the last century. It is shown that the main problem in creation of APDs with high gain was appearance the local uncontrolled breakdowns in the p-n junctions. The following topics concerning the stages of developments of the modern SiPMs are discussed: • Two different approaches in development of APDs: improvement of technology and search for new designs to avoid the local breakdowns. • Differences in performance of traditional SPAD devices and MAPDs. • A long way from APD to MAPDs via the avalanche MIS and MRS structures. • Three advanced designs of MAPDs. • A new avalanche detector – micropixel avalanche phototransistor.
        Speaker: Prof. Ziraddin Sadygov (JINR)
        Slides
      • 11:10
        Physics of SiPMs 30m
        Speaker: Dr Elena Popova (MEPhI)
        Slides
    • 11:40 12:25
      Review Talks
      • 11:40
        SiPMs in Astroparticle Physics 45m
        Speaker: Dr Razmick Mirzoyan (MPI Physik)
        Slides
    • 12:30 14:00
      Lunch Break 1h 30m
    • 14:00 14:45
      Review Talks
      • 14:00
        SiPMs for PET - An Important but not Exclusive Factor 45m
        Speaker: Prof. Karl Ziemons (Aachen University of Applied Sciences)
        Slides
    • 14:45 15:45
      SiPM Producers
      Convener: Prof. Patrick Achenbach (Mainz University)
      • 14:45
        Broadcom 30m
        Speaker: Mr Claudio Piemonte (Broadcom)
      • 15:15
        Hamamatsu 30m
        Speaker: Mr Ardavan Ghassemi (Hamamatsu)
        Slides
    • 15:45 16:15
      Coffee Break 30m
    • 16:15 17:15
      SiPM Producers
      Convener: Prof. Patrick Achenbach (Mainz University)
      • 16:15
        SensL: Application Specific Testing and Qualification of SiPM 30m
        SensL SiPM sensors have been in mass production for many years. To ensure quality and reliability, characterisation and qualification procedures are in place that can process high volumes in a short amount of time. Increasingly SiPMs are being used in new applications, in particular as the reciever element in LiDAR systems. LiDAR is a ranging technique that typically uses NIR light which conventional SiPMs have only minimal senstivity to. We have developed a new fully-CMOS silicon process to improve the NIR sensitivity of SiPM for these applications. These R-Series sensors can achieve >10% PDE at 905 nm. Although SensL's standard characterisation and qualification procedures can be applied to these new sensors, different applications bring some specific additional requirements. In particular, automotive applications have strict qualification requirements that are specified in the AEC-Q102 standard that specifically covers optoelectronic components. We will discuss how this automotive qualifications standard is applied to SensL SiPM sensors.
        Speaker: Dr Deborah Herbert (SensL Technologies)
      • 16:45
        KETEK: Characterization of SiPMs for Large Scale Applications 30m
        -
        Speaker: Mr Eugen Engelmann (KETEK)
        Slides
    • 17:15 17:55
      EU Projects
      Convener: Prof. Patrick Achenbach (Mainz University)
      • 17:15
        SENSE - Ultimate Low Light Level Sensor Development 20m
        SENSE is a project funded by the EC Horizon 2020 as FET Open Coordination and Support Action (CSA). Within the project a European R&D roadmap towards the ultimate LLL sensor was developed and with the experts group the progress in developments with respect to the roadmap will be monitored. In addition, a collaboration between several labs experienced in measuring photosensors was developed to characterize LLL sensors and standardize measurements and analysis procedures. Further cooperation especially with industrial partners is in preparation. Dissemination of results and the communication between all involved partners and interested parties is a main aspect of the project. Therefor the SENSE website provides all kind of information related to photosensors, starting from a calendar with interesting events over information about the project itself to portraits of experiments working with photosensors and the different test facilities. The SENSE forum allows for communication between all involved actors. In the future a database containing the results of SiPM characterization is planned. Several outreach activities and special trainings for students are also part of the project and will be extended in the future. The consortium has four partners: DESY (Coordinator), Germany; UNIGE, Switzerland; MPP, Germany and KIT, Germany. Several international experts on all parts of LLL developments are involved in the expert or working group of the project.
        Speaker: Katharina Henjes-Kunst (DESY)
        Slides
      • 17:35
        FAST: Fast Advanced Scintillator Timing 20m
        Scintillator-based detectors have been very successful in high energy physics (HEP) calorimetry, medical imaging, and many other applications. In particular, the potential of such detectors to achieve precise timing information is of increasing importance for those applications. The demand to discriminate between closely spaced bunch trains in future highest luminosity accelerators and to deliver space points in addition to the traditional back-to-back line of response reconstruction algorithms of positron emission tomograph (PET), requires a further step in time resolution, i.e. below 100ps. The implications of such a radical improvement in time resolution come with dramatic benefits in many domains. HEP will profit from a significant increase in detection efficiency and the health sector from an unprecedented improvement in imaging quality and image reconstruction time. Such a ‘paradigm’ change, however, must go hand-in-hand with a similar break in the interdisciplinary domain of photon detection. Therefore, new expertise must be gained in the fields of scintillators, photodetectors, as well as electronics to develop ultrafast timing scintillator-based detectors. The Trans Domain COST Action (FAST, Fast Advanced Scintillator Timing) aims to establish a multidisciplinary network that brings together European experts from academia and industry to ultimately achieve scintillator-based detectors with time precision better than 100ps and provides an excellent training opportunity for researchers interested in this domain. The FAST COST (Action TD1401) started on November 20 2014 and will end on November 19 2018. In this presentation we will present the FAST Action on its main achievements.
        Speaker: Mr Claudio Piemonte (Broadcom)
        Slides
    • 18:00 20:50
      Welcome Reception 2h 50m
    • 09:00 09:20
      Welcome by the Mayor of Schwetzingen Dr. René Pöltl
      Convener: Prof. Herbert Orth (GSI)
    • 09:20 10:45
      Photon Detection Efficiency
      Convener: Prof. A. Nepomuk Otte (Georgia Tech)
      • 09:20
        PDE Introduction 10m
        Speaker: A. Nepomuk Otte (Georgia Tech)
        Slides
      • 09:30
        PDE Measurement for Digital SiPMs: Comparison Between Pulsed and Continuous Light Methods 20m
        The information extracted from the characterization of Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPM) is a key element to their future technological development. These experimental data allow SiPM manufacturers to refine their devices and make them more efficient. As there are several methods of characterization across the scientific community, it is essential to define measurement standards to obtain reliable and comparable results. One important characteristic that defines SiPMs is the Photon Detection Efficiency (PDE). In the literature, the characterization of PDE is done in three different ways : the photocurrent method [Bonanno 2009], the pulsed-light counting method [Otte 2006] and the continuous-light counting method [Piemonte 2012]. Despite minor differences, each approach is able to determine the absolute PDE with a good degree of reliability and repeatability [Zappalà 2016]. However, for special type of SiPMs some of the aforementioned methods could be more appropriate. For example, digital SiPMs are built most of the time following an application-specific architecture where data is formatted in situ and transfered digitally. We elaborate on the distinctions between each method and compare their applicability to the measurement of absolute PDE for digital SiPM.
        Speaker: Frédéric Vachon (University of Sherbrooke)
        Slides
      • 09:50
        Characterization of VUV-Sensitive SiPMs for LXe Scintillation Light Detection in nEXO 20m
        The nEXO experiment will operate an ultra-low background TPC filled with $5$\,tons of isotopically enriched liquid Xenon~(LXe) to search for the neutrinoless double beta ($0\nu\beta\beta$) decay of Xe-136. The detector will use $4\,\text{m}^2$~of SiPM tiles operated at~$-104^{\circ}\text{C}$ to collect the scintillation light from any events in the xenon. There are strong requirements on the SiPM performance, light collection efficiency and background levels to achieve an excellent energy resolution. Detecting the $0\nu\beta\beta$-decay would have wide-spread implications for particle physics. The SiPMs have to be sensitive to the vacuum-ultraviolet (VUV) scintillation light of LXe at $178\,\text{nm}$ which is not given for off-the shelf SiPMs. The development and characterization of such VUV-sensitive SiPMs for nEXO has already produced promising results: (1) measured limits for the radio-isotope content of SiPMs (manufactured by Foundation Bruno Kessler, FBK) are consistent with requirements, (2) the photo-detection efficiency exceeds $15\,\%$ for FBK and Hamamatsu Photonics SiPMs at $178\,\text{nm}$, (3) dark noise and correlated avalanche rates are better than the upper limits adopted by nEXO of $50\,\text{Hz}/\text{mm}^2$ and $20\,\%$, respectively. The nEXO collaboration is continuing to work with SiPM manufacturers to further improve performances. nEXO also examines the VUV-reflectance of SiPM. Detector samples are immersed in a LXe cell and irradiated with photons at a wavelength of $178\,\text{nm}$ at the LXe laboratory at M{\"u}nster University. The reflectance for given incident angles can be derived as the ratio of the reflection rate off of the SiPM surface and the reference rate without sample -- both measured with a secondary detector for a wide reflectance angle range. Other investigations focus on possibly different behaviours of SiPMs in high electrostatic fields as present in the final TPC by nuisance measurements at various electric field strengths. In this talk, we give an overview of the current VUV-sensitive SiPM characterisation efforts within the nEXO collaboration focussing on PDE and surface reflectance studies.
        Speaker: Mr Michael Wagenpfeil (Erlangen University)
        Slides
      • 10:10
        Techniques for Characterizing Light Source Emission Statistics at Single-Photon Level 20m
        Characterizing the underlying processes contributing to a light field has wide ranging applications throughout physics. For instance, knowledge of the mode structure is vital for engineering sources of nonclassical light that minimize loss and decoherence of quantum information due to coupling to unwanted modes. Photon-number statistics are used to characterize a variety of optical systems including single-photon sources [1–3], cavity QED [4,5], and lasers [6,7].  The aim of this talk is to review the techniques, in particular the ones investigated in INRIM (Italy), for characterizing the statistical emission of single-photon or low-light sources [8-11] and eventually their mode structure reconstructions [12]. This is very important in the context of photon detection efficiency (PDE) characterization of single-photon sensitive detector like, SPADs and silicon photomultipliers (SiPM). The PDE measurements of SiPM are generally based on light sources that are assumed presenting Poissonian statistics in the photon emission, but this has to be properly tested. Furthermore, a validation of the measurement techniques is on going thanks to pilot comparisons lead by INRIM between European national metrological institutions on the measurement of the second-order Glauber auto-correlation function in the VIS-NIR and at telecom wavelength for both pulsed and CW sources. These comparisons are carried on under the European metrological project EMPIR 14IND05 "MIQC2" [13], from the skills developed and results obtained in the previous project on metrology at single photon level, namely IMERA+ qu-Candela [14], EMRP IND06 "MIQC" [15], and EMRP EXL05 "SIQUTE" [16].   [1] C. Kurtsiefer, S. Mayer, P. Zarda, and H. Weinfurter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 290 (2000). [2] D. Press, S. Gotzinger, S. Reitzenstein, C. Hofmann, A. Loffler, M. Kamp, A. Forchel, and Y. Yamamoto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117402 (2007). [3] W. Schmunk, M. Gramegna, G. Brida, I. P. Degiovanni, M. Genovese, H. Hofer, S. Kuck, L. Lolli, M. G. A. Paris, S. Peters, M. Rajteri, A. M. Racu, A. Ruschhaupt, E. Taralli, and P. Traina, Metrologia 49, S156 (2012). [4] M. Aßmann, F. Veit, M. Bayer, M. van der Poel, and J. M. Hvam, Science 325, 297 (2009). [5] M. Hennrich, A. Kuhn, and G. Rempe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 053604 (2005). [6] D. Elvira, X. Hachair, V. B. Verma, R. Braive, G. Beaudoin, I. Robert-Philip, I. Sagnes, B. Baek, S. W. Nam, E. A. Dauler, I. Abram, M. J. Stevens, and A. Beveratos, Phys. Rev. A 84, 061802 (2011). [7] M. Aßmann, F. Veit, M. Bayer, C. Gies, F. Jahnke, S. Reitzenstein, S. Hofling, L. Worschech, and A. Forchel, Phys. Rev. B 81, 165314 (2010). [8] C.J. Chunnilall, I. P. Degiovanni, S. Kück, I. Müller, A. G. Sinclair, Optical Engineering 53 (8), 081910 (2014) [9] E. Moreva, P. Traina, J. Forneris, I.P. Degiovanni, et al., Physical Review B 96 (19), 195209 (2017) [10] I.P. Degiovanni, S. Polyakov, A. Migdall, H.B. Coldenstrodt-Ronge,  I. A. Walmsley, F. N. C. Wong, "Single-Photon Generation and Detection" (Chapter 7: "Hybrid Detectors"), Elsevier Inc. 2013. [11] D.G. Monticone, K. Katamadze, P. Traina, E. Moreva, J. Forneris, I. P. Degiovanni et al. Physical review letters 113 (14), 143602 (2014) [12] E.A. Goldschmidt, F. Piacentini, I.R. Berchera, S.V. Polyakov, S. Peters, S. Kück, I.P. Degiovanni et al. Phys. Rev. A. 88 (1), 013822 (2013) [13] http://empir.npl.co.uk/miqc2/ [14] http://www.quantumcandela.org/ [15] http://projects.npl.co.uk/MIQC/ [16] https://www.ptb.de/emrp/siqute-home.html
        Speaker: Dr Paolo Traina (INRIM)
        Slides
      • 10:30
        PDE Discussion & Summary 15m
        Speaker: A. Nepomuk Otte (Georgia Tech)
        Slides
    • 10:45 11:15
      Poster Session at Coffee Break
      List of Posters
    • 11:15 12:35
      Miscellaneous and Others
      Convener: Dr Dieter Renker (TUM)
      • 11:15
        Instrumentation for the Scintillator Upgrade of IceTop 20m
        IceCube is a cubic-kilometer neutrino detector installed in the ice at the geographic South Pole. It comprises a deep-ice detector (installed between 1450 and 2450 m under the ice surface) and a surface array called IceTop, featuring 162 tanks with frozen water. More than five thousand photomultipliers detect the Cherenkov light emitted by charged particles; these detections are used to reconstruct energy and direction of those particles and their progenitors which have cosmic origins. Over the past twelve years, snow accumulation on top of the IceTop tanks has reached depths that affect the sensitivity to low energy cosmic-ray showers. The IceCube Collaboration plans to install a few hundred homogeneously spaced scintillator detectors as a new calibration instrument for the IceTop tanks. Each detector features extruded plastic scintillator bars and wavelength shifting fibers, which collect the scintillation light produced by minimum ionizing particles and guide it to a silicon photomultiplier. Custom readout electronics allows for the precise measurement of light pulses from a single photo-electron to tens of thousands and features nanosecond time resolution, with the ability to resolve time development of complex light pulses of order one hundred nanoseconds in duration. Prototypes of such detectors have been installed over the last austral summer. 
The project will also serve as a platform to develop instrumentation, electronics and an infrastructure system that could be scaled to a future large array, spanning up to 20 thousand sensors distributed over 75 km^2.
        Speaker: Delia Tosi (WIPAC / University of Wisconsin Madison)
        Slides
      • 11:35
        Studies of SiPM Behavior under Continuous Light Illumination 20m
        This work reports on the behavior of the Silicon Photomultiplier (SiPM) detector under continuous light illumination. Large area ~ 1 cm$^2$ hexagonal SiPM S10943-2832(X) produced by Hamamatsu HPK for the single mirror small size telescope SST-1M (one of the projects proposed for the implementation of the small size telescopes of the Cherenkov Telescope Array CTA) has been used for studies. The bias circuit of the SiPM contains a resistor meant to prevent the sensor from drawing high current and cut high frequency electronic noise. However, this resistor together with SiPM quenching resistor introduce a voltage drop during light detection at the SiPM input, impacting the stability of its operation. Electrical (i.e. breakdown voltage, gain, pulse amplitude), noise (dark count rate and optical crosstalk) and optical (i.e. photon detection efficiency) parameters were studied under five different light illumination levels from 3 MHz up to 1 GHz of photons per SiPM micro-cell at room temperature (T = 25 $^0$C). The experimental results were compared with toy Monte Carlo simulation. From our studies, a model have been developed in order derive the parameters needed to account for it at the data analysis level. Also, a solution is proposed to compensate for the voltage drop and will be presented.
        Speaker: Dr Andrii Nagai (University of Geneva)
        Slides
      • 11:55
        SiPM Experience from more than Six Years Operation of FACT 20m
        The First G-APD Cherenkov Telescope (FACT) is pioneering the usage of SiPM in Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes. Its camera consists of 1440 SiPM, each coupled to a solid light-guide and an individual read out. In October 2011, the camera was installed in a refurbished telescope structure with a mirror area of 9.5m^2 at the Canary island La Palma, and successful data taking started within few hours. Since then, FACT is taking data whenever observation conditions permit, with the primary goals of gaining long-term experience with operation of SiPM under harsh conditions as well as monitoring a set of variable extragalactic high energy gamma-ray sources. For the science goal, stable performance of the photo detectors is crucial and therefore has been studied in great detail. Special care has been taken with regards to keep the gain of the SiPM constant despite their temperature varying by more than 25 deg. This is reached through implementation of a feedback system that regularly adjusts the applied voltage to the sensor temperature as well as to the current drawn due to varying night-sky brightness. Several independent long term measurements were conducted to analyze and verify SiPM stability. As example, dark count spectra, which also make for an excellent self calibration mechanism, were used to study and model the temperature dependencies. Trigger thresholds are adjusted to the night-sky background by measuring the current drawn by individual groups of pixels. With these methods, the performance of the FACT camera is kept stable without the need for any external calibration device. While each of the 1440 SiPM has collected a charge of more than ???C so far, there is no indication of any ageing or any other sensor-related problems. The exceptional reliability of the system allows to operate FACT as the only Cherenkov telescope so far in a fully robotic way. In this talk, the results of the long term performance studies and experience gained from the six years operation of SiPM will be presented.
        Speaker: Mr Dominik Neise (ETH Zurich)
        Slides
      • 12:15
        Prototyping of Large-Size SiPM Based Detector Modules in IACTs 20m
        MAGIC is a system of two imaging atmospheric Cherenkov telescopes (IACTs) operated by an international collaboration at the Canary island of La Palma. Like all large-size IACTs (>12 m diameter), MAGIC uses imaging cameras consisting of more than a thousand photomultiplier tubes (PMTs). The modular assembly of the camera and the design of its structure offer the possibility to install a maximum of six additional prototype detector modules next to the PMTs, at the vertexes of the hexagonal structure and to operate them in parallel with the camera. We developed three silicon photomultiplier (SiPM) based detector modules using SiPMs from Hamamatsu, SensL and Excelitas. Their purpose is to investigate the potential use of SiPMs in large-size IACTs. The capacitance of SiPMs limits the size (speed and gain) of the active area of a single sensor. Therefore we use a matrix of up to nine 6x6 mm² SiPMs to achieve an active area comparable to a 1-inch PMT and actively sum the individual signals to a composite output. The first SiPM prototype was installed in 2015 in one of the open corners in the MAGIC-1 camera. In 2017 two second-generation modules, with improved photon detection efficiency and fill factor, were installed. All three SiPM modules are integrated into the standard data taking procedure, providing data for a performance comparison during real telescope operations. SiPM detector modules were calibrated using single-photoelectron spectra and the F-factor (excess-noise) calibration method. Artificial light pulses as well as real Cherenkov light from air showers, are used for our performance comparison. Details of the methods will be presented.
        Speaker: Mr Alexander Hahn (MPI Physik)
        Slides
    • 12:35 12:40
      Conference Photo 5m
    • 12:40 14:00
      Lunch Break 1h 20m
    • 14:00 15:20
      Large Scale Characterization and Reliability
      Convener: Nikolay Anfimov (JINR)
      • 14:00
        Large Scale Characterization Introduction 10m
        Speaker: Dr Nikolay Anfimov (JINR)
        Slides
      • 14:10
        Large Scale Characterization and Quality Assurance Tests for CALICE AHCAL "Engineering Prototype" 20m
        The CALICE collaboration have studies different concepts for the hadronic calorimeters for a future linear collider detector. The Analog Hadronic Calorimeter (AHCAL) concept is a sampling calorimeter of tungsten or steel absorber plates using plastic scintillator tiles read out by silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) as active material. SiPMs evolved to match scintillator light wavelength, allows to optimize tile design for scalable production. Optimization of tile geometry allows to use industry standard package and PCB placement procedures After having demonstrated the capabilities of the technology in the “physics prototypes”, the AHCAL “engineering prototype”, consisting of 24K channels, was built this year with the focus on proving scalability to a full AHCAL detector with more than 8 million channels. This talk will focus on the Large scale characterization tests and quality assurance tests of the surface mounted SiPMs used in the production of the AHCAL “engineering prototype”.
        Speaker: Dr Yonathan Munwes (Heidelberg University)
        Slides
      • 14:30
        Large Scale Characterization of SiPMs in the MEG II Experiment 20m
        The upgrade of the MEG experiment, called MEG II, highly relies on the application of SiPMs. Two main detectors use a large amount of SiPMs for highly granular readouts of scintillation light. The Timing Counter uses 6144 NUV-type SiPMs from AdvanSiD. We tested all the sensors before the assembly with respect to I-V characteristics and sensitivity to the scintillation light. During the experiment, the performance and the radiation damage level have been monitored using a dedicated laser system as well as the sensor currents. The LXe detector uses 4092 VUV-type SiPMs from Hamamatsu Photonics. One device is composed of independent 4 sensor chips, totaling 16,368 chips, and all of them were tested individually at room temperature before the assembly for the full characterization. During the experiment, the SiPM characteristics, such as gain and PDE, have been monitored and calibrated by means of alpha sources and LEDs in the detector. In this talk, we will present the methods and results.
        Speaker: Dr Yusuke Uchiyama (PSI)
        Slides
      • 14:50
        Large Scale Characterization of Si-APDs @ FAIR/GSI 30m
        During the last decades, large area APDs (Avalanche Photo Diodes) reached more and more popularity as readout devices e.g. for calorimeters in various high energy- and nuclear physics experiments. In many cases the APD characteristics need to be individually known to allow for a careful match of the operating parameters to the particular experimental needs and conditions like temperature, expected irradiation dose, desired gain etc.. As a consequence, the experiment dependent requirements on the sensor performance have to be reflected in the large scale characterization process. Potentially occurring variations in designated sensor parameters within large scale production should be identified and classified during this process. For this purpose a modularly usable large scale characterization facility for APDs and eventually also Si photo sensors in general has been established at FAIR/GSI. Motivated from the experience of the large volume characterization work, several R&D topics are being pursued as e.g. a varying behavior under different irradiation conditions.
        Speaker: Dr Andrea Wilms (GSI)
        Slides
    • 15:20 15:50
      Poster Session at Coffee Break
      List of Posters
    • 15:50 16:50
      Large Scale Characterization and Reliability
      Convener: Nikolay Anfimov (JINR)
      • 15:50
        Modular and Custom SiPM for the Mu2e Electromagnetic Calorimeter 20m
        The Mu2e electromagnetic calorimeter has to provide precise information on energy, time and position for ~100 MeV electrons. It is composed of 1348 un-doped CsI crystals, each coupled to two large area Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPMs). A modular and custom SiPM layout, consisting of a 3 × 2 array of 6 × 6 mm$^2$ UV-extended monolithic SiPMs, has been developed to fulfill the calorimeter requirements and a pre-production of 150 prototypes has been provided by three international firms (Hamamatsu, SensL and Advansid). A detailed quality assurance process has been carried out on the photosensor pre-production   and on the first production batchs: the breakdown voltage, the gain, the quenching time, the dark current and the Photon Detection Efficiency (PDE) have been determined for each monolithic cell of each SiPMs array.  A sample from each vendor has been then exposed to neutrons generated by the Elbe Positron Source facility (Dresden), up to a total fluency of $\sim$ 8.5 $\times$ 10$^{11}$ n$_{1 MeV}$/cm$^2$. The test results are also shown. The dependence of the dark current on the device temperature and on the applied bias voltage has been evaluated as well. This paper also presents an electrically induced annealing technique that provides a partial recovery of the SiPMs damaged by neutrons.
        Speaker: Dr Ivano Sarra (INFN)
        Slides
      • 16:10
        Scintillation Tile Hodoscope for the PANDA Barrel Time-Of-Flight Detector 20m
        The PANDA barrel time-of-flight detector will be conducted as scintillator tile, covering phi=1m x 2m long surface. The area is segmented in 2000 tiles, each of which has a dimension of 9x3cm2 and 5mm thickness. Photons are detected at two ends of each tiles, at each end 4 SiPMs are combined serially to increase the effective sensitive are of SiPM. Tiles are mounted on a large PCB backplane with MMCX coaxial connectors. The PCB backplane integrates signal transmission lines with the microstriplines technique. In 16 multilayer PCB board 5-6 signal lines are stacked vertically within the width of about 1mm. The signal processing and digitisation circuit is concentrated on one end of the backplane, realising a nearly cable-less design. The current prototype shows reasonably homogeneous performances over the surface. The average time resolution is about 50ps in standard deviation. In this paper, we present the ground design of the detector based on the Technical Design Report, accepted recently by FAIR, and recent topics toward mass production.
        Speaker: Dr Ken Suzuki (ÖAW)
        Slides
      • 16:30
        Large Scale Characterization Discussion & Summary 20m
        Speaker: Dr Nikolay Anfimov (JINR)
        Slides
    • 17:00 19:00
      Tours of Palace & Garden 2h
    • 19:00 21:00
      Visit to ‘Blaues Loch’ - Beer Tasting and Snacks 2h
    • 09:00 10:30
      Timing Properties (FAST Action WG3 Meeting)
      Convener: Stefan Gundacker (CERN)
      • 09:00
        Timing Properties Introduction 10m
        Speaker: Dr Stefan Gundacker (CERN)
        Slides
      • 09:10
        Time Resolution Measurement with Analog SiPMs: Measurements and Setup Examples 20m
        Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPM) are multi-cell photodetectors that have been studied and improved over the last few years. They are used in several applications ranging from the detection of single photons to multiple photons. Among others properties, the single-photon time resolution (SPTR) is an important characteristic of the SiPMs which has been studied in depth over the last few years by different groups employing different setups and techniques. The single-photon time resolution has been considered one possible limiting factor for the coincidence time resolution (CTR), where SiPMs are coupled with scintillators in applications like positron emission tomography (PET). It is also becoming increasingly important in low-light applications such as Cherenkov-light detection, and in SiPM-based light-detection and ranging (LIDAR). In this contribution we will discuss different measurements setups and readout methodologies used by various groups to characterize the SPTR of analog SiPMs with a critical view of the possible sources of error and with an overview of the practical aspects. In addition we will discuss the measurement related aspects such as the type of laser, attenuation of light and the identification of single photon events. The two commonly used techniques to measure timing are waveform acquisition and ASIC readout. In waveform acquisition, the SiPM output is amplified and acquired directly using an oscilloscope for the signal to be then analyzed to extract the timing histogram and SPTR. In ASIC readout the output is either a time stamp or a discriminated signal that can further be digitized by an external TDC. Irrespective of the readout technique, only the single photon events are selected for measuring the signal time delay against a reference. The SPTR is affected by the choice of the excess bias and by the discriminating threshold: they both have always to be specified. By examining the SPTR measurement techniques for analog SiPM, we intend to have comparable parameters for the measurements performed by groups across several fields and institutions.
        Speaker: Dr Fabio Acerbi (FBK)
        Slides
      • 09:30
        Case Study of Digital SiPMs 20m
        Single-photon timing resolution (SPTR) is a key parameter for SiPM that influences the system-level timing performance, e.g. in applications such as positron emission tomography (PET), correlated photon detection or ranging (LiDAR). Appropriate standardization of SPTR in digital silicon photomultipliers (D-SiPMs) encounters a challenge as it is dependent of the electronic readout architecture, which is inherently different for individual D-SiPMs. Additionally, comparing analog SiPMs (A-SiPMs) to D-SiPMs in a meaningful way is limited by their different intrinsic device natures. In this presentation, we start from the basic definition of SPTR and apply it to the characterization of several D-SiPMs cases, such as multichannel digital silicon photomultipliers (MD-SiPMs), 3D digital SiPM (3DdSiPM) and the digital photon counter (DPC). We compare the D-SiPMs’ architectures and their impact on the timing performance including a description of on-chip testing circuits that has been used for characterization. Architecture independent and dependent parameters are identified and discussed in order to build a standardization flow. We specify the measurement conditions and system settings in order to obtain a fair comparison between architecture-independent parameters, and a recommendation for a standardized measurement procedure. In addition, we will outline the main differences in SPTR measurements between D-SiPMs and A-SiPMs and present a subset of conditions and standardized parameters that could enable a comparison between them.
        Speaker: Mr Esteban Venialgo (Delft University of Technology)
        Diapositivas
      • 09:50
        Multi-Photon Time Resolution and Applications 20m
        There are many applications demanding for a photon-number-resolving detection of light pulses, some of them also require an extreme timing resolution at the multi-photon level (TOF PET, LIDAR, 4D calorimetry). Silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) operate in both detection modalities with outstanding performance and appear to be a well-recognized detector of choice in such applications. Therefore, it is necessary to understand all factors and limitations affecting the time resolution of SiPM-based detectors. Indeed, the time resolution of SiPMs is extensively studied in experiments and Monte-Carlo simulations mostly with respect to scintillation detection. These approaches clarify some basic features, however, there is still a lack of analytical models and results describing multi-photon time resolution (MPTR), especially for an arbitrary pulse shape. This study is focused on how the single photon time resolution (SPTR) influences the MPTR, because it is still a less clarified point with respect tofactors as, for example, photon detection efficiency (PDE) of a photodetector. Our goal is to represent and analyze the MPTR analytically as a function of the most important SiPM parameters (SPTR, PDE, single electron response pulse shape) and the light pulse (number of photons, rise and decay times or FWHM). This analytical model of the MPTR and its correspondence with some experimental results (exponential and Gaussian shapes of the light) will be presented and discussed.
        Speaker: Dr Elena Popova (MEPhI)
        Slides
      • 10:10
        Timing Properties Discussion & Summary 20m
        The rapidly growing use of silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) makes it necessary to standardize the various parameters related to this device with the final goal of rendering measurements comparable within different research groups and the industry. This summary talk will focus on the intrinsic timing parameters of SiPMs, i.e. the single photon time resolution (SPTR). We will present our reasoned definition of the SPTR for the analog and digital SiPM with an explanation and justification of the corresponding terms via detailed physical models. The link to applications, e.g. time of flight positron emission tomography, will additionally rationalize our approach. After discussing the main definitions we will show how a typical measurement setup can be conceived and consider in detail all components and parameters of the setup for a reliable and comparable SPTR measurement. A further focus will be given on the intrinsic difference of analog and digital SiPM with the goal of establishing a common platform for comparing both types of photodetectors in terms of their timing performance.
        Speaker: Dr Stefan Gundacker (CERN)
    • 10:30 11:00
      Poster Session at Coffee Break
      List of Posters
    • 11:00 11:45
      Review Talks
      • 11:00
        Review on Cryogenic Applications 45m
        Speaker: Fabrice Retiere (TRIUMF)
        Slides
    • 11:45 12:30
      Miscellaneous and Others
      Convener: Dr Dieter Renker (TUM)
      • 11:45
        Application of SiPMs and MCP-PMTs in the PANDA PID detectors 20m
        PANDA is a hadron physics experiment at the FAIR facility at GSI which will employ a high intensity antiproton beam of up to 15 GeV/c to do high precision studies of, among others, objectives like charmonium spectroscopy and search for gluonic excitations. These measurements require a robust and compact PID system with excellent timing capabilities placed inside a magnetic field of $>$1 Tesla. For charged tracks above a Cherenkov threshold of $\beta$ $>$ 0.68 DIRC-type detectors will be used, while for slower particles time-of-flight (TOF) detectors were chosen. Due to the harsh boundary conditions in the focal plane vicinity of the PANDA Cherenkov detectors (DIRC) microchannel-plate (MCP) PMTs were identified as the only suitable photon sensors. After solving a long-standing aging problem these devices are currently the best-performing photon sensors for cases when single photon detection with a sub 100 ps time resolution is required inside strong magnetic fields. Due to serious radiation hardness issues readout efforts with digital SiPMs were abandoned for this type of detector. For slow particles a new TOF detector (PANDA barrel TOF) with $<$100 ps time resolution built of a large array of small 5 mm thick scintillating tiles and read out by analogue SiPMs will surround the interaction point in about 0.5 m distance. In this case every traversing particle will produce thousands of photons in the scintillator and each readout sensor will be faced with multiple (~100) photons. Under these circumstances the radiation hardness of the SiPMs is of lower importance. After a period of R&D work and several improvements of the scintillator/SiPM configuration a time resolution of ~50 ps was obtained almost independently of the hit position of the traversing particle. In this talk the various R&D steps towards the final configuration and their results will be presented and discussed. We started with small (30x30x5 mm$^{3}$) tiles read out by single SiPMs at opposite side, tested long and thin (~120x5x5 mm$^{3}$) scintillating rods with the same readout, and finally ended up with long and wide (~120x30x5 mm$^{3}$) scintillating tiles readout by four serially connected SiPMs at the opposite sides.
        Speaker: Dr Albert Lehmann (Erlangen University)
        Slides
      • 12:05
        Applicability of Digital SiPMs in RICH Detectors 20m
        Silicon photomultiplier (SiPM) seems to be a promising photon sensor to be used in future large-scale Ring Imaging Cherenkov (RICH) detectors of the modern experiments due to their potentially low costs, compactness and immunity to magnetic field. The only drawbacks are relatively high dark counts and radiation hardness issues. Digital SiPMs integrating most of the front-end electronics on chip may offer even more to conventional SiPMs: more compactness, superior timing resolution at the level of tens of ps, SPAD-size position resolution and individual control on SPADs. In June 2012 an aerogel RICH detector prototype based on dSiPMs from Philips named Digital Photon Counter (DPC) was tested with a mixed hadron beam at CERN. The prototype consisted of a 20x20 cm DPC array with 2304 pixels of 4x4 mm size each. Dead time of the DPC was 720 ns. In order to reduce the dark count rate and raise the photon detection efficiency the detector was cooled to -40°C in addition to disabling individual SPADs. Cherenkov rings with 12 photoelectrons in average for relativistic particles were observed, single photon timing resolution was estimated at 50 ps, inter-pixel crosstalks were 4%. Signs of radiation damage was observed during this test. Later we studied radiation damage for Philips DPC cooled down to -20°C with a proton beam at FZJ reaching a proton fluence of 4*10^11 p/cm^2. Dark count rate of damaged DPC as function of proton fluence and temperature is studied. Annealing effect during 7 hours at +45°С was also studied. Absolute PDE measured for a few DPC pixels and corrected for dead time is about 20% for 470 nm wavelength. Measured characteristics of the current DPC design prevents from using it in RICH application mainly due to large dead time and susceptibility to radiation. Desired dSiPM parameters for RICH applications are proposed for discussion.
        Speaker: Mr Sergey Kononov (BINP)
        Slides
    • 12:30 14:00
      Lunch Break 1h 30m
    • 12:30 14:00
      Scientific Organizing Committee Meeting
      Convener: Prof. A. Nepomuk Otte (Georgia Tech)
    • 14:00 15:30
      Nuisance Parameters
      Convener: Dr Alberto Gola (FBK)
      • 14:00
        Noise Sources in SiPM 20m
        Speaker: Dr Alberto Gola (FBK)
        Slides
      • 14:20
        Statistical Modeling of SiPM Noise 20m
        SiPM noises are very complicated in general due to a presence of correlated processes, namely, crosstalk and afterpulsing. From a statistical point of view, SiPM noises are stochastic processes contributing to a total SiPM response charge. The charge is a random variable which could be completely characterized by its probability distribution. Partial characterization of the SiPM response by its mean and variance is the most important practical case. However, discrimination and analysis of specific noise contributions in the total response and optimization of SiPM operations appear to be rather uncertain because of their correlations (the means and variances could not be summed up for dependent variables) and their different dependencies on a bias voltage (relative weights are changeable). Excess noise factor (ENF) approach extends a well-known measure of an avalanche multiplication noisiness to any stochastic processes especially initiated by a non-random unit input quantity (single electron, single-fired cell). Therefore, all specific noise contributions are represented, distinguished, and analyzed by corresponding ENFs, and the total response ENF is approximately equal to a product of the specific ENFs. The report presents an overview of statistics and models related to the specific ENFs of the gain, dark counts, crosstalk, and afterpulsing as well as some practical recommendations on their applicability for analysis, optimization, and energy resolution related applications of the SiPM.
        Speaker: Dr Sergey Vinogradov (Lebedev Physical Institute)
        Slides
      • 14:40
        SiPM Noise Measurements with Waveform Analysis 20m
        Speaker: Mr Eugen Engelmann (KETEK)
        Slides
      • 15:00
        Nuisance Parameters Discussion 30m
        Speaker: Dr Alberto Gola (FBK)
    • 15:30 16:00
      Poster Session at Coffee Break
      List of Posters
    • 16:00 17:40
      Nuisance Parameters
      Convener: Dr Alberto Gola (FBK)
      • 16:00
        Direct Measurement of Optical Crosstalk in SiPMs Using Light Emission Microscopy 20m
        Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPMs) are attractive light detectors for high energy and astroparticle physics experiments. They are compact in size, have fast (few ns) response time, operate at lower voltage compared to classical photomultiplier tubes, are insensitive to magnetic fields, and the newer samples offer photon detection efficiencies of > 40%. The optical cross-talk effect, whereby light emitted during the initial avalanche breakdown process may be absorbed by neighboring cells causing additional breakdowns, can degrade the performance of SiPMs. We describe ongoing work at the Max Planck Institute for Physics in Munich where we constructed a light emission microscopy setup to directly measure the emission due to optical cross-talk in SiPMs. This method provides the most precise measurement of cross-talk as well as allows one to inspect and directly visualize the existence of hot cells, which could over-proportionally contribute to the noise of a SiPM chip. We will report on the comparison of the cross-talk measurements by using the method of light emission microscopy and the traditional "blind" measurement based on amplitude measurements. Also, by using the light emission microscopy, we are exploring the possible influence of the topology of a SiPM on the cross-talk; this could help developing methods for further reducing the cross-talk. We present an overview of our setup and measurements performed. This work is part of SENSE, a roadmap for the ideal low light level sensor development and funded by the European Commission under Future and Emerging Technologies Open Coordination and Support Action.
        Speaker: Dr Derek Strom (MPI Physik)
        Slides
      • 16:20
        Experimental SiPM Parameter Characterization from Avalanche Triggering Probabilities 20m
        Efficient and low noise detection of vacuum ulta-violet (VUV) scintillation photons is critical for the nEXO experiment to achieve its projected sensitivity to zero-neutrino double beta decays. VUV SiPMs are being developed by Fondazione Bruno Kessler and Hamamatsu Photonics to fulfill nEXO’s requirements. It is desirable to operate the SiPMs at high over-voltage in order to achieve maximum efficiency and single photon sensitivity while minimizing electronics power dissipation. However, the over-voltage is limited by cross-talk and after-pulse that eventually drive the detector performances. In order to understand the over-voltage dependence in detail, we have built a new model by extracting the electron and hole avalanche triggering probabilities using VUV and Infra-red light sources. Then we show that we can describe the over-voltage dependence of the dark noise, after-pulsing and cross-talk rates using a minimum set of parameters and extract the relative contribution of electrons vs holes for each process. We also show that this model predicts the behavior of the IV (current-voltage) curve. The data that are used in this analysis are for Hamamatsu VUV4 at temperatures ranging from -40 to -110C. In this talk, we will also review a method for extracting after-pulsing rates and discuss a new concept for probing the behavior of charge carrier produced deep in the silicon using two-photon ionization.
        Speaker: Mr Giacomo Gallina (TRIUMF)
        Slides
      • 16:40
        Suppressing Optical Crosstalk in SiPMs 20m
        Compared to conventional photomultiplier tubes (PMTs), silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs) based on multi-cell geiger-mode avalanche photodiodes (GAPDs) have advantages with regards to photon detection efficiency, compactness, robustness and tolerance of both magnetic fields and intense light sources. In addition, SiPMs can be cost effective for applications that require many channels with small unit area. Because of these advantages, SiPMs are starting to replace PMs in many applications. When used in the cameras of Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov telescopes, the optical crosstalk of SiPMs needs to be reduced in order to suppress accidental triggers due to the high rate of night sky background caused by scattered starlight and moonlight, and the fluorescence of excited molecules in the atmosphere. In this contribution, the propagation properties of optical photons in SiPMs are investigated through systematic measurements of the optical crosstalk with varying SiPM pixel and GAPD cell sizes and with and without coatings on the SiPMs. It was observed that a significant portion of the optical crosstalk is mediated by the coating. The propagation of optical photons in the bulk silicon of the SiPM is also discussed.
        Speaker: Hiroyasu Tajima (Nagoya University)
        Slides
      • 17:00
        Simulation of SiPM Noise 20m
        Speaker: Dr Johannes Breuer (Siemens Healthineers)
        Slides
      • 17:20
        Nuisance Parameters Discussion & Summary 20m
        Speaker: Dr Alberto Gola (FBK)
    • 19:00 22:30
      Conference Dinner in 'Schlossrestaurant' 3h 30m
    • 09:00 10:30
      Radiation Hardness
      Convener: Prof. Erika Garutti (Hamburg University)
      • 09:00
        Radiation Hardness Introduction 10m
        Speaker: Thomas Tsang (BNL)
        Slides
      • 09:10
        Neutron Radiation and Recovery Studies on SiPMs 20m
        SiPM lost its performance characteristics when exposed to high dose of neutrons. However, the distinct hallmark of SiPMs, low dark count and excellent photon-number-resolving capability, can be recovered by thermal annealing. Several Hamamatsu and FBK series SiPMs are characterized before and after exposure of up to 1010 neutron/cm2 dosage using a 14 MeV neutron generation source. Collectively, we established that the typical orders of magnitude increase in dark current upon neutron irradiation can be lowered substantially after processing them with a novel thermal annealing procedure, and single-photon detection are to some extent recovered. Moreover, we found no significant difference on neutron damaged behavior when SiPMs are irradiated at room or liquid nitrogen temperatures.
        Speaker: Thomas Tsang (BNL)
        Slides
      • 09:50
        Study of Evolution of MPPC Properties Induced by Neutrons 20m
        During my talk I would like to show and discuss results of evolution of MPPC properties during irradiation by neutrons. Two models of Multi-Pixel Photon Counters: S13360-3050CS and S13360-6050CS from Hamamatsu with different size (3x3 mm$^{-2}$ and 6x6 mm$^{-2}$, respectively) and the same subpixel pitch size (50 $\mu m$) were irradiated by neutrons from two sources: PuBe source with continuous energy spectrum up to 11~MeV and mono-energetic 4.8~MeV neutrons produced in (d,d) reaction. For both cases the neutron fluence/(MPPC size) in a range of 10$^{9}$ mm$^{-2}$ was achieved. The observed changes of current-voltage characteristics and breakdown voltage evolution for neutron fluence increase will be shown . The energy resolution degradation of 662 keV gamma line from $^{137}$Cs, obtained for non-irradiated GAGG scintillator, as a function of neutron fluence will be presented. Finally, calculated contribution of noise component in measured energy resolution will be also shown.
        Speaker: Dr Slawomir Mianowski (National Centre for Nuclear Research)
        Slides
      • 10:10
        Assessment of Photodetection Performance of Analog and Digital SiPMs Exposed to Cold Neutrons 20m
        Small Angle Neutron Scattering (SANS) technique uses cold or thermal neutrons for investigation of soft and condensed matter. Significant developments in microelectronics enabled the use of scintillation-based pixelated neutron detectors that exploit Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPM) for detecting visible light generated within a scintillator, in our case a 1 mm thick Ce-doped 6Li-glass [1]. We investigated the dark signal [1], the breakdown voltage, and the photon detection efficiency (PDE) performances [2] of three SiPM technologies: two analog ones and one based on digital counting of avalanche events. The temperature dependence of the dark signal performance, and the breakdown voltages of SiPMs were additionally investigated. The following photodetector arrays have been characterized: SensL Series-C 12×12 array C-30035-144P, Hamamatsu 8 × 8 MPPC array S12642-0808PB-50, and digital Philips DPC3200-44-22 module. We irradiated the photodetector arrays with cold neutrons (lambda = 5 Å) at the KWS-1 instrument [3] of the Heinz Maier Leibnitz Zentrum (MLZ) in Garching, Germany, up to a dose of 6E12 n/cm². During the irradiation campaigns, the SiPM detectors were at all times fully operational, and the measurements were performed partially in-situ. In this work, we discuss the measurement methods, and instrumentation developed for these tasks. Special emphasis is put on a custom measurement system implemented in a joint effort by the company aSpect Systems GmbH and the Central Institute for Electronic Systems (ZEA-2) of the Forschungszentrum Jülich for temperature and position sensitive measurement of wavelength dependent PDE in the range between 300 nm and 1100 nm. Finally, the results of the characterization of the SiPM arrays carried out before, during, and after cold neutron irradiation are presented. References [1] D. Durini et al., “Evaluation of the dark signal performance of different SiPM-technologies under irradiation with cold neutrons” Nucl. Instr. and Meth. A 835, 99–109, 2016, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2016.08.016 [2] S. Kumar, D. Durini, C. Degenhardt and S. van Waasen “Photodetection Characterization of SiPM Technologies for their Application in Scintillator based Neutron Detectors”, Journal of Instrumentation, Vol. 13, Jan. 2018, https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-0221/13/01/C01042 [3] Heinz Maier-Leibnitz Zentrum et al., „KWS-1: Small-angle scattering diffractometer “Journal of large-scale research facilities, 1, A28, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.17815/jlsrf-1-26
        Speaker: Prof. Daniel Durini Romero (FZ Jülich / INAOE)
        Slides
    • 10:30 10:50
      Coffee Break 20m
    • 10:50 11:45
      Radiation Hardness
      Convener: Prof. Erika Garutti (Hamburg University)
      • 10:50
        Effects of Neutron and Gamma Radiation on SiPMs 20m
        The effects of radiation damage in SiPMs from gamma rays has been measured and compared with the damage produced by neutrons. SiPMs were exposed to 60Co gamma rays at the Solid State Gamma-Ray Irradiation Facility at Brookhaven National Lab and the Institute for Nuclear Research (Atomki) in Debrecen, Hungary. The gamma ray exposures ranged from 1 krad to more than 1 Mrad and the neutron exposures ranged from 109 n/cm2 to 1012 n/cm2. The main effect of gamma ray damage is an increase in the noise and leakage current in the irradiated devices, similar to what is seen from neutron damage, but the level of damage is considerably less at comparable high levels of exposure. In addition, the damage from gamma rays saturates after a few hundred krad, while the damage from neutrons shows no sign of saturation, suggestive of different damage mechanisms in the two cases. The change in optical absorption in the epoxy window of the SiPMs due to radiation was also measured, as well as the effect of thermal heating due to the increased dark current on the breakdown voltage. These various effects due to radiation and a comparison between neutrons as gammas are discussed in this paper, as well as discussion of the possible effects mechanisms for producing this damage in both cases.
        Speaker: Mr Sean Stoll (BNL)
      • 11:10
        Characterization of Radiation Damaged SiPMs 20m
        SiPMs with 4384 pixels of 15 µm x 15 µm produced by KETEK have been irradiated with reactor neutrons to fluences between 10^9 and 5 10^14 cm-2. After the irradiation C-V, I-V, and current transients with and without pulsed light have been performed at +20°C and –30°C. No annealing, in addition to the annealing during the transport and the measurements, has been applied. Outside of the measurements the SiPMs were stored at –25°C From the C–V measurements at 26 V, which were taken at 25 frequencies between 100 Hz and 2 MHz, the SiPM electrical parameters, the pixel capacitance, Cpix, the quenching resistance Rq and the capacitance Cq parallel to the quenching resistor, have been determined using a simple R–C model. It is found that the value of Cpix neither depends on dose nor on neutron fluence, whereas the value of Rq increases for fluences above 10^12 cm-2. As expected for a poly-Si resistor, Rq also increases with temperature. The frequency dependence of the measured complex resistance at high fluences shows effects of radiation-induced defects. The C–V measurements at a fixed frequency have been used to investigate the doping profile and electric field of the SiPM. Indications for a small decrease of the electric field in the vicinity of the p+n junction are found, which are attributed to donor (P) removal. The I–V data without illumination are used to determine the breakdown voltage, Vbd. We note that for the SiPMs investigated, we found previously that the breakdown voltage determined from the I–V data is approximately 1 V higher than the voltage obtained by extrapolating the linear Gain–V relation to Gain = 1. We identified the latter with the turn-off voltage, Voff, the voltage at which the Geiger discharge stops. The method of the minimum of the Inverse Logarithmic Derivative, ILD, as well as a fit of the I–V data assuming a quadratic dependence of ILD on V are used to determine Vbd. For the non-irradiated and the SiPMs irradiated to low fluences, the ILD method gives a Vbd value, which is systematically higher by about 100 mV. For the fluence dependence of Vbd it is found that it is constant up to 5 10^12 cm-2 and then increases. The I–V data are also used to estimate the dependence of the Dark Count Rate, DCR, on voltage, fluence and temperature. The DCR increases by up to seven orders of magnitude with neutron irradiation. Using the concept of Pixel Occupancy, eta, the reduction with voltage of the dynamic range of the SiPM as a photo-detector is estimated. At the highest fluences the occupancy at low excess voltage is so high, that the SiPM is expected not be any more a useful photodetector. By integrating the current-transients without illumination pulse-area spectra for gate widths of 15, 30, 45, 60 and 75 ns are obtained and their moments determined. From the variances the DCR as a function of excess voltage, neutron fluence and temperature is derived. The results are compared to the DCR results discussed above. An analysis of the uncertainty related to the difference of Vbd and Voff for the gain and of the excess noise factor, which could not be determined at high DCR, is presented. From the current transients of the SiPM illuminated by a blue pulsed LED with a pulse width of ≈3 ns, the performance of the SiPMs as light detectors as a function of neutron fluence and temperature is determined. The number of photons, which was chosen to give about 100 Geiger discharges per pulse, is sufficiently high, so that signal and dark pulses are well separated. The results are compared to the results of the occupancy method discussed above. The main emphasis of the talk is on the methods developed for characterizing the properties and performance of radiation-damaged SiPMs.
        Speaker: Prof. Robert Klanner (Hamburg University)
        Slides
      • 11:30
        Radiation Hardness Discussion & Summary 15m
        Speaker: Thomas Tsang (BNL)
        Slides
    • 11:45 12:30
      Electrical Properties
      • 11:45
        Review on SiPM Readout Circuitry 30m
        Review of SiPM model, front end circuits for SiPM readout, digitization techniques, System-On-chip solution and new trends.
        Speaker: Dr David Gascon (University of Barcelona)
      • 12:15
        Electrical Properties Discussion & Summary 15m
        Speaker: Dr David Gascon (University of Barcelona)
        Diapositivas
    • 12:30 14:00
      Lunch Break 1h 30m
    • 14:00 14:45
      Review Talks
      • 14:00
        SiPM Applications in Particle Physics Experiments 45m
        Nowadays many new scintillator-based and Cherenkov-radiation-based detectors in particle physics use or plan to use Silicon Photomultipliers (SiPMs) for reading out the produced light pulses. The talk will present some of the considered detector concepts, the status of the corresponding development and the SiPM features most relevant for the different applications.
        Speaker: Prof. Hans-Christian Schultz-Coulon (Heidelberg University)
        Slides
    • 14:45 15:30
      Review Talks
      • 14:45
        Metrological Characterisation of Single-Photon Avalanche Diodes 45m
        Single-photon avalanche diodes (SPADs) are currently the most used detectors for the single-photon detection in many quantum technologies, such as quantum communication, quantum key distribution, quantum biology, etc. [1, 2]. The success of such technologies greatly depends on the performance of the single-photon detector used. In the last decade, the performance of such SPAD detectors, e.g. quantum efficiency, dead time, dark counts, gating rate, etc., has been significantly improved due to the great advances in new avalanche quenching technologies and cooling systems [2, 4]. Basically, two types of SPAD detectors are nowadays commercially available: gated and free-running SPAD detectors [5, 6]. In both cases, the metrological characterization of their optical parameters is essentially required to fully guarantee the reliability of the quantum detection system. Therefore, the PTB, and other National Metrological Institutes (NMIs), are putting great efforts in developing novel measurement methods and calibration facilities, which allow the traceable characterization of the optical parameters of these detectors by using reference standards [7, 8]. In this conference, the detailed metrological characterization of Si- and InGaAs- SPAD detectors including the measurement setup, traceability and uncertainty analysis will be presented. Acknowledgment: This work has been supported by EMPIR-14IND05 “MIQC2” (the EMPIR initiative is co-funded by the EUH2020 and the EMPIR Participating States). [1] Robert H. Hadfield, “Single-photon detectors for optical quantum information applications”, Nature Photonics 3, 696–705 (2009) [2] Damien Stucki, et al., “Photon counting for quantum key distribution with peltier cooled InGaAs/InP APDs”, Journal of Modern Optics, 48, Issue 13, 1967-1981 (2001) [3] I. Prochazka, et. al., “Recent achievements in single photon detectors and their applications”, Journal of Modern Optic, 5, Issue 9-10 1289-1313 (2004) [4] Jun Zhang, et al., “Advances in InGaAs/InP single-photon detector systems for quantum communication”, Light: Science & Applications, (2015) [5] http://www.micro-photon-devices.com [6] https://www.idquantique.com [7] M. López, et al, “Detection efficiency calibration of single-photon silicon avalanche photodiodes traceable using double attenuator technique, Journal of Modern Optics 62, S21 – S27, 2015. [8] G. Porrovecchio, et al., “Comparison at the sub-100 fW optical power level of calibrating a single-photon detector using a high-sensitive, low-noise silicon photodiode and the double attenuator technique”, Metrologia 53, 1115-1122 (2016).
        Speaker: Dr Marco Lopez (PTB)
        Slides
    • 15:30 16:00
      Coffee Break 30m
    • 16:00 17:50
      Nonlinearity and Saturation
      Convener: Dr Sergey Vinogradov (Lebedev Physical Institute)
      • 16:00
        Nonlinearity and Saturation Introduction 10m
        Speaker: Dr Sergey Vinogradov (Lebedev Physical Institute)
        Slides
      • 16:10
        Statistics and Models of SiPM Nonlinearity and Saturation 20m
        SiPM is an inherently nonlinear detector. Nonlinearity and saturation effects are originated from excess random losses of photon detection events due to a limited number of SiPM cells and non-instant recovery of the cells. From a statistical point of view, SiPM nonlinearity and saturation could be completely characterized by a probability distribution of a SiPM response in a required range of incident light signals. Partial characterization could be provided by a mean and variance of the response distribution, and it is the most important practical case for SiPM calibration and evaluation of the SiPM energy resolution beyond a linear operating range. Known analytical models of the SiPM probability distribution could not simultaneously combine key factors affecting SiPM nonlinearity and saturation, namely, a limited number of cells, recovery process, crosstalk, and afterpulsing. Therefore, corresponding approximate expressions for the mean and sometimes also for the variance are proposed and used for the calibration. However, such combined expressions could hardly be associated with solid probabilistic grounds. The report presents an overview of the state-of-art and modern developments in statistics and models of the SiPM nonlinearity and saturation as well as some practical recommendations on their applicability for calibration and energy resolution related applications of the SiPM.
        Speaker: Dr Sergey Vinogradov (Lebedev Physical Institute)
        Slides
      • 16:30
        Physics and Experimental Studies of SiPM Nonlinearity and Saturation 20m
        Silicon Photomultiplier (SiPM) is often considered at the basic level as an array of Geiger mode APD cells which are connected in parallel, operate independently, and produce a sum of binary signals equal to number of fired cells. However, many specific effects make SiPM much more complicated device than just a collection of independent GM APDs. Namely, during Geiger discharge and recovery of the SiPM cell a p-n junction potential drops down and turns back to its initial value resulting in non-binary response of the cell with loss of responsibility due to lower probability of avalanche triggering and lower gain in case of triggering. recovering. Correlated effects (crosstalk and afterpulsing) result in loss of independency of cell operations due to a random number of false events - fired cells.These effects are also sensitive to effective value of the cell potential thus being dependent on a state of the recovery process. These simple factors are very important in considerations of SiPM nonlinearity and saturation as they lead to a quite complicated dependence of an output SiPM signal on input photons (SiPM response curve), especially for an arbitrary light pulse shape. Generally, the response curve has three different parts determined by a number of impinging photons (photoelectrons) per cell. One can assume that the linear operating regime is characterized by the low number of photoelectrons per cell Npe << 1, the oversaturation appears at Npe >> 1, and the nonlinear or saturated regime is between them. It is obvious that the cell recovery process plays a key role in a behavior of the response curve for the saturated second and third regime in their dependence on light intensity. To understand it in detail, one should start from single cell studies and then takes into account all these effects in their interactions and complications associated with multi-cell operations of the SiPM. Physics and experimental studies of the single-cell SiPMs and different types of SiPMs related to the nonlinearity and saturation will be presented.
        Speaker: Dr Elena Popova (MEPhI)
        Slides
      • 16:50
        Dynamic Range Characterization of SiPM with a Double Light Superposition Method 20m
        We present a new method, Double Light Superposition (DLS) to characterize the dynamic range (DR) of silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs). This self-calibrated technique does not need the calibration procedures for the intensity of the light source from single photon to the level of SiPM saturation, makes the measurement easy and robust, thus can be a candidate of standard for DR measurement of SiPM. It is also benefit to be compatible to characterize the recovery time of SiPM, thus deducing the maximum photon-counting rate for the device operation. The setup of the DLS method includes two identical LEDs, coupled to an optical integrator with fly-eye lens; two short-pulse drivers, with the same frequency and phase, to drive the two LEDs and adjust their light intensity independently. The SiPM functions as both a device under test and a photon meter that is illuminated by the uniform pulsed light in a light tight box. The pulsed signal outputted from the SiPM is inputted to an oscilloscope, to which a synchronous signal correlated to the dual pulsed signals is fed as a trigger to reject the dark counts. The procedure steps of DLS method are as follow: (1) Adjust the intensity of each pulsed light from the dual LED to achieve an output of $\sim1$ MFPN (mean fired pixel number) from the SiPM respectively. It is set as $N_{init}$ and is equal to the MPEN (mean photoelectron number) under few photons level, and an initial point (photoelectron number, fired pixel number) $=(N_{init},N_{init})$ is thus obtained. Then, the two pulse light are superposed (i.e., doubled) and re-measure the MFPN from the SiPM, the second point of ($2N_{init}$, MFPN) is obtained. (2) Increase the light intensity of each light pulse to achieve the same MFPN as the previous superposed one, respectively, and then superpose the two light beams and re-measure the outputted MFPN. (3) Follow this alternative, double increasing and self-calibrated measurement procedure, the dependence of the fired pixel number on photoelectron number can be obtained. We will report DLS method in detail in this conference, and present the results and discussion on the dynamic range of NDL latest C series EQR-SiPM with high density of micro cell $(10^4/mm^2)$.
        Speaker: Mr Jian Liu (Beijing Normal University)
        Slides
      • 17:10
        Method and Experimental Setup to Measure SiPM Saturation 20m
        We present the experimental method and a corresponding setup to measure the response of SiPM as a function of incoming light intensity. In particular, the saturation behavior is investigated. The method introduces a calibrated quantity to measure the incoming number of photons independently of the photon detection efficiency and the optical crosstalk of the SiPM. In this way, different sensors operated at different bias voltages can be compared. The experimental setup is based on a picosecond laser diode with programmable intensity. Fiber optics is used to split the beam in order to measure the laser intensity with a reference diode in parallel to the SiPM. A XYZ-positioning system in combination with an engineered diffuser is used to ensure a uniform exposure of the SiPM surface. The SiPM signal is read out with a charge-to-digital converter synchronized to the laser pulses. The measured response curves for several SiPM are presented and compared to different response models.
        Speaker: Mr Sascha Krause (Mainz University)
        Slides
      • 17:30
        Nonlinearity and Saturation Discussion & Summary 20m
        Speaker: Dr Sergey Vinogradov (Lebedev Physical Institute)
        Slides
    • 18:00 20:00
      Wine Tasting 2h
    • 09:00 10:35
      Cryogenic Properties
      Convener: Adam Para (Fermilab)
      • 09:00
        Cryogenic Properties Introduction 15m
        Speaker: Adam Para (Fermilab)
        Slides
      • 09:15
        Review of Readout Technics for Cryogenic Experiments 20m
        Speaker: Dr Wataru Ootani (Tokyo University)
        Slides
      • 09:35
        Cryogenic Readout Electronics for a MPPC Based Array Operating at Liquid Xenon Temperature 20m
        We present the performances and characterization of an array made of Hamamatsu S13370-3050CN (VUV4 generation) Multi-Pixel Photon Counters for the detection of VUV scintillation light in liquid xenon based applications. The array is readout as a single channel and it is capable of single photon detection making the device a promising option for future generation of neutrino and dark matter detectors based on liquid xenon targets. The electronics board encloses a low power consumption preamplifier stage, operating at liquid xenon temperature. In the present configuration, a single operational amplifier serves 16 individual MPPCs (corresponding to 1.44 cm$^2$ of active surface) forming a macro cell. The electronics is capable to readout up to 4 macrocells. The operational amplifier selected for the realization of the prototype is the current feedback Analog Devices AD8011. The layout does not prevent the use of different models in case of higher performance requirements or for operations at lower temperatures. A biasing correction circuit, based on Digital To Analog Converters suitable for cryogenic applications, is used for the gain equalization of photosensors with different breakdown voltages. Detector characteristics, noise analysis and performance will be discussed along with the preliminary radioactivity screening assessment of the preamplifier unit.
        Speaker: Dr Adriano Di Giovanni (New York University Abu Dhabi)
        Slides
      • 09:55
        SiPMs as Photo-Sensors in a Liquid Xenon Time Projection Chamber (TPC) 20m
        Liquid Xenon Time Projection Chambers (LXeTPC) are used in rare event searches for Dark Matter, neutrinoless double beta decay or in applications as Compton telescope or camera where the noble medium offers a combination of scintillation light and ionization that can be used to build large, uniform 3D position sensitive detectors. We test the feasibility of replacing the common used photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) by SiPMs in such a detector. As most commercially available SiPMs are not sensitive to the scintillation light of xenon in the VUV regime at 178nm, a special construction of the SiPMs, or a special treatment of commercial devices is neccesary. We operate a test stand to observe the operational stability and to measure the sensitivity, crosstalk and afterpulse properties of three VUV-sensitive SiPM samples in liquid xenon at -100°C. A 1" PMT is operated simultaneously for reference while scintillation light is provided by a $^{241}Am$ source immersed in liquid xenon.
        Speaker: Mr Christopher Hils (Mainz University)
        Slides
      • 10:15
        Analytical Approach to Fundamental Properties of SiPMs at Cryogenic Temperatures 20m
        Silicon photomultipliers are important in liquid argon detectors of short-baseline neutrino oscillation experiments. Furthermore, in spin-polarized proton and deuteron targets of photoproduction experiments, SiPMs are used for recoil identification down to absolute zero temperature. For these and future applications a characterization over the full cryogenic temperature range is obligatory. Based on physical principals, an analytical description of the temperature dependence of breakdown voltage and single-cell capacity was developed. It enables constant gain control from room down to liquid helium temperature. To calculate the number of ionizations in the depletion layer and thereby the avalanche triggering probability, Wolff's theory for high electrical fields was adopted. This approach lead to predictions of the photon detection efficiency and the crosstalk probability. Finally, the single-cell signal-to-noise ratio was investigated to find the optimum operational temperature. All these calculations were supported by analyzes of pulse height spectra and forward as well as reverse characteristic curve measurements.
        Speaker: Mr Maik Biroth (Mainz University)
        Slides
    • 10:35 11:05
      Coffee Break 30m
    • 11:05 12:00
      Cryogenic Properties
      Convener: Adam Para (Fermilab)
      • 11:05
        Commissioning of VUV-MPPCs for MEG II Liquid Xenon Detector 20m
        A liquid xenon photon detector based on highly granular scintillation readout by 4092 VUV-sensitive MPPCs is in preparation for the MEG II experiment. The VUV-MPPCs have been commissioned and operated in the liquid xenon detector in 2017. The performance of the VUV-MPPCs measured in the commissioning as well as the results from an in-beam test of the liquid xenon detector will be presented.
        Speaker: Dr Wataru Ootani (University of Tokyo)
        Slides
      • 11:25
        Overview on Experimental Setups to Study SiPM Parameters Down to Cryogenic Temperature 20m
        Many important SiPM parameters, like breakdown voltage, signal shape, gain, dark count rate, afterpulses probability present significant temperature variations. Therefore, a study of these parameters in a wide temperature range, down to cryogenic temperatures allows to have a closer look to the physical phenomena staying behind this temperature dependence and eventually find equivalent operating conditions independent of temperature. Moreover, since some different physical phenomena’s which lead to same SiPM parameter, but may show different variation with temperature. Therefore, studies of those physical phenomena’s as a function of temperature may be only the way to separate them and find the dominated one. This work reports the overview on experimental set-ups developed for studies of SiPM parameters as a function of temperature. Moreover, it should lead to guide line for future scientists who would like to build their set-ups for temperature studies. Work includes practical suggestions in design, calibration and usage of such kind of set-ups, which was collected by authors during building their own facilities.
        Speaker: Dr Andrii Nagai (University of Geneva)
        Slides
      • 11:45
        Cryogenic Properties Discussion & Summary 15m
        Speaker: Adam Para (Fermilab)
        Slides
    • 12:00 12:20
      Miscellaneous and Others
      Convener: Dr Dieter Renker (TUM)
      • 12:00
        Characterization of Position Measurement Error, Position Resolution and Photon Number Discrimination for Position-Sensitive SiPM 20m
        Silicon photomultipliers (SiPM) is considered to be a good replacement for photomultiplier tube (PMT) and avalanche photodiodes (APD) in high energy physics, which benefits from its high internal gain, good compactness, excellent timing performance, robustness and insensitivity to magnetic fields. However, pixelated SiPM array generally used in high-resolving scintillation imaging applications, shows its drawbacks of large number of readout channels and limited position resolution by SiPM pixel size. Position-Sensitive Silicon Photomultiplier (PS-SiPM) has been emerged as a special kind of SiPM during the past years; it possesses excellent spatial resolution with greatly reduced readout channels, which enables its promising application, for example, in high resolution PET. Since the PS-SiPM is a relatively new type of SiPM, the standardization of PS-SiPM characterization has not been established, which results in hard comparison of devices from different producers. In this conference, we will propose characterizing methods for the major characteristics of PS-SiPM, including the photon-number resolution, position measurement error and position resolution by taking a 2-D tetra-lateral PS-SiPM developed by NDL (Novel Device Laboratory, Beijing) as an example.
        Speaker: Ms Yu Peng (Beijing Normal University)
        Slides
    • 12:20 13:00
      Concluding Session
      Convener: Prof. Herbert Orth (GSI)
      • 12:20
        Summarizing Discussions 20m
        Slides
      • 12:40
        Publication Strategy for a White Paper 20m
    • 13:00 13:00
      End of Conference