We study the time evolution of the number of charm mesons after the kinetic freeze-out of the hadron gas produced by a central heavy-ion collision. The $\pi$ D$^*$ $\rightarrow$ $\pi$ D$^*$ reaction rates have $t$-channel singularities that give contributions inversely proportional to the thermal width of the D. The ratio of the D$^0$ and D$^+$ production rate can differ significantly from those predicted using the measured D$^*$ branching fractions.